A baking powder, a slogan and a book that outlived both

By Ines Keane

The Edmonds Cookery Book started life as advertising. The New Zealand Ministry for Culture and Heritage’s history site calls the first edition a 50-page pamphlet of recipes promoting baking powder and jellies, offering “economical everyday recipes and cooking hints”. Wikipedia agrees it was created by a baking-powder maker as a marketing tool. Over a century later, it is the country’s best-selling book.

Where the business began

The NZHistory page says Thomas John Edmonds was a grocer who started a baking products business in Lyttelton, after customers complained about the baking powder they used. Whanganui Regional Museum’s archivist, writing in a 2023 museum article, gives a slightly different start: Edmonds, aged 20, arrived in Christchurch from London with his wife in 1879 and opened a small general store, then began making baking powder at the back of the shop.

Both sources agree on the first batch: 200 tins, in 1879. The NZHistory page says it was sold with the claim that baking would be “sure to rise”. The museum says the tins sold slowly, so Edmonds gave free samples across Canterbury, and none were returned. The museum also says legend credits him with the slogan “It is sure to rise, Madam”, which inspired the rising-sun logo. NZHistory says the trademark was a rising sun with cakes. We keep the museum’s hedge: it calls the slogan a legend.

The book

NZHistory says the book was first published in 1908 as the Sure to rise cookery book, after a small giveaway booklet the year before. It says only two first editions are known to survive. The Whanganui article agrees on two surviving copies and adds that housewives could request a free copy and every newly engaged couple received one. Wikipedia places the free copy for engaged couples in the 1940s, which may be a different practice or a different date. We do not decide.

The two sources count the first edition differently. NZHistory says 50 pages. The museum says 50 recipes and cooking hints. Wikipedia says 50 pages. A page count and a recipe count are different things.

Editions in order

The museum article and Wikipedia between them give a run of landmarks:

  • 1908: first edition.
  • 1910: second edition, print run of 150,000 (NZHistory).
  • 1930: first edition with photographs (Wikipedia).
  • 1955: the 7th Deluxe edition adds New Zealand recipes such as toheroa soup and tree tomato jam (museum). Wikipedia calls 1955 the first “De Luxe” edition, after which the book became a paid product.
  • 1967: tripe removed (museum, 8th edition).
  • 1971: a gas-oven edition (both).
  • 1976: spiral binding, so the book lies flat, and the first to give metric and imperial measurements (both).
  • 1980s: microwave cooking appears (museum). Wikipedia puts a microwave baking section in 1988.
  • 1988: the “Food for Invalids” section is removed in the 27th edition (museum).
  • 1993: international foods and nutrition sections (both).
  • 2008: centenary edition (Wikipedia).
  • 2012: an edition with more than 500 recipes (NZHistory calls it the 66th; Wikipedia agrees on the year and the recipe count).
  • 2016: the 69th De Luxe edition (Wikipedia).

These lists come from different pages, so a missing date in one is not evidence of a missing edition.

The book as an object

Wikipedia says that before the book, Edmonds printed recipes on the lids of baking powder tins. It says the cover began showing the factory in 1955, when the book became a paid product, and quotes the journalist Ron Palenski calling the book as much a part of New Zealand kitchens as a stove and knife. NZHistory adds that gas and microwave versions have also been produced, and that the cover appeared on the “E” in a 2008 New Zealand Post stamp series, A to Z of New Zealand. Wikipedia describes the book as a Kiwiana item. Those last two points are about reputation, not method, and we keep them short.

Sales

NZHistory says over three million copies sold since 1908, “by far” the best-selling New Zealand book. Wikipedia says over three million by 2015 and the best-selling New Zealand-published book as of 2019. Neither source gives an audited figure, and we treat “over three million” as a floor.

The factory

NZHistory says a factory was built in 1922 on Ferry Road in Woolston, Christchurch, and demolished in 1990, and that the city council acquired a major part of the factory garden in 1991. Wikipedia says the cover began showing the factory in Linwood, Christchurch, from 1955, and that it was demolished in 1990. The two sources name different suburbs, Woolston and Linwood, for the same building, so we flag it.

The museum article says Edmonds won a prize at the 1890 Dunedin Exhibition. It says over one million tins had sold by 1912, and that by 1929 about three million tins a year were sold in a country of 1.5 million people. It also says production and administration moved to Auckland in 1982, and that the company is now part of Australian-owned Goodman Fielder. These are the museum’s figures.

What kind of sources these are

NZHistory is a government heritage site, editorially written. The Whanganui piece is a museum archivist’s newspaper column. Wikipedia is open-edit. None is an audited sales record.

What the sources do not say

They do not say who wrote the first edition. They do not name any author or editor. They do not give a recipe that we could reproduce, and we would not invent one.

What we left out

Prices, claims about authorship, comments on user pages, and any brand claim beyond the dates above.

Roam first. Shop later.

/sell-with-sephari/

Scroll to Top