By Rafe Calder
It is a piece of marshmallow in a chocolate coat, shaped like a fish. It is also, in New Zealand, a unit of praise.
The phrase “Give that kid a chocolate fish” turns up in the Wikipedia article on the sweet as the standard way to say a job was done well. The sweet itself is plain. The habit around it is the interesting part.
What it is
Wikipedia describes a traditional New Zealand confection, 5 to 8 cm long, made of pink or white marshmallow under a thin layer of milk chocolate. The ripples that stand for scales are made by moving the fish under a blower, which slides the unset chocolate back. Small versions are called sprats, and a common variant is solid orange-flavoured milk chocolate. Wikipedia says several manufacturers make it, and that the best known is Cadbury.
Where it began
Two sources trace it to a Dunedin baker. Radio New Zealand, the public broadcaster, links the earliest chocolate fish to Richard Hudson, a UK-born baker who moved to New Zealand in the 1860s, set up a bakehouse in Dunedin and, around 1884, began making chocolate. Advertisements for “Hudson’s Chocolate Fish” followed. The Spinoff, a news and culture site, agrees on the man and the year, but notes that no precise launch date is recorded and that the story is “widely traced” to him rather than proved. Its evidence is advertising: chocolate fish were popular by the early 1900s.
Wikipedia gives a different, vaguer start. It says the sweet has been made since at least 1903, though early versions may not have included marshmallow, and that marshmallow fish were produced in Dunedin in 1937. These sit alongside the Hudson story rather than against it, but they do not confirm it.
The company changed hands. The Spinoff says Hudson & Co merged with Cadbury Bros Ltd in 1930 to form Cadbury Fry Hudson Co, which it calls the main local maker for the rest of the twentieth century. Radio New Zealand says early chocolate fish moulds were found when the Cadbury factory in Dunedin was demolished, and suggests they belong in Te Papa.
How it became a reward
Radio New Zealand puts the first uses as rewards in the 1920s, and the earliest it found is from 1929, at the Pohangina Valley Rifle Club. The Spinoff says the sweet has been a prize for achievements since at least the 1920s, “from rifle club children to vaccination drives in 2021”, and quotes the idea that it works like a currency for good deeds. Radio New Zealand quotes a Spinoff writer tying the custom to a New Zealand character trait and saying it is “tied to ritual”. Our reading: a fish worth a few minutes’ pleasure is cheap enough to give often and small enough that nobody feels grand receiving it.
Odd places it has turned up
The Spinoff lists a few. In 1937, two Christchurch shop owners were fined for Sunday trading; their defence was a single chocolate fish sold to a hospital patient. In 1992, a minister was handed a chocolate fish as an award. In 2019 an Auckland petrol station stopped selling cigarettes and gave chocolate fish to smokers instead.
Wikipedia adds that Tip Top sold a chocolate fish ice cream in the late 1990s and early 2000s, and that in 1996 a “Great New Zealand Cadbury Chocolate Fish Day” was created in May to support two charities. Radio New Zealand says the sweet entered the dictionary in the 1990s and became popular through the television show Son of a Gunn, whose character Thingee was a devoted fan; viewers mailed thousands of chocolate fish to the show.
Dates in order
- 1884, approximately: Hudson’s begins making chocolate, according to Radio New Zealand and the Spinoff.
- 1903: the sweet has been made since at least this year, according to Wikipedia.
- 1920s: use as a reward begins, according to Radio New Zealand.
- 1929: the earliest reward use found, at a rifle club, according to Radio New Zealand.
- 1930: Hudson & Co merges with Cadbury Bros, according to the Spinoff.
- 1937: marshmallow fish are produced in Dunedin, according to Wikipedia.
- 1996: Chocolate Fish Day is created, according to Wikipedia.
- 2018: Cadbury announces it is moving operations from Dunedin to Australia, according to the Spinoff.
- 2023: Cadbury stops making the 20 g fish, according to Wikipedia.
Side by side
The sources disagree about a price quarrel. Radio New Zealand puts a public outcry over the cost of a chocolate fish in the 1960s, when the pound gave way to the dollar, and says it reached Parliament’s Question Time. Wikipedia places a parliamentary question about chocolate fish prices in 1970. Both agree on the shape of the story: decimalisation, a price rise and a politician. They differ on the year. The Spinoff gives 1969 for the rise itself, and calls it a 60 per cent increase over two years, which sits between the two.
Makers today are another gap. Wikipedia says Cadbury stopped making the 20 g fish in 2023 but kept sprats in its Favourites boxes, and that as of 2024 Queen Anne makes a 50 g fish and a 14 g “fish bites”. The Spinoff says Cadbury moved its operations to Australia and later stopped making its large fish. We have not found a source that lists every current maker.
What we left out
Prices, other than the mention of the quarrel about them. Ingredient lists beyond the two layers, because no source gave one. The fish-shaped chocolates made in other countries, which Radio New Zealand says lack the same cultural weight, and for which no second source was given.
What kind of sources these are
Wikipedia is an open encyclopaedia. Radio New Zealand and the Spinoff are news outlets and, in the Spinoff’s case, a piece of cultural commentary dated November 2025. None is a company history, and no source from the makers was read.
Quick answers
What is a chocolate fish made of? According to Wikipedia, pink or white marshmallow covered in a thin layer of milk chocolate, shaped like a fish and 5 to 8 cm long.
Why do New Zealanders give chocolate fish as a reward? Radio New Zealand says the custom dates to the 1920s, with the earliest reward use it found in 1929, and links it to recognising a job well done.
Who made the first chocolate fish? Radio New Zealand and the Spinoff both trace it to Dunedin baker Richard Hudson, around 1884, though the Spinoff says no precise launch date is recorded.
Related on this site: milford-track-fiordland-great-walk, otago-central-rail-trail-old-railway-bike-ride, hundertwasser-toilets-kawakawa-heritage
Roam first. Shop later.