Two jars, one name, and a shelf that went bare

By Isla Quinn

Dark. Salty. Sticky on a knife. Scrape it thin on buttered toast and you have a New Zealand breakfast. Scrape the British version thin on the same toast and you have a slightly different one, because the two spreads are not the same recipe.

Where it started

Marmite was first made in England in 1902, according to FoodNavigator. The first Marmite sold in New Zealand was imported from England, says the National Business Review, citing the maker’s own site.

Making it in Christchurch

By 1919 New Zealand had its own version, an Associated Press report says, and it differs in taste from the English one. The Library of Congress’s law blog tells it in more steps: the First World War interrupted supply from England, Sanitarium began making Marmite in Christchurch under licence, and it registered the Marmite trademark in New Zealand in 1920. The National Business Review adds that the recipe was altered in the 1930s and sugar added, and says the maker’s site gives the mid-1940s for Christchurch production of the finished New Zealand style. So the sources date the start of local making and the start of the local recipe differently. The maker’s timeline also records that the Christchurch factory was gutted by fire in 1966.

Same name, different spread

Sanitarium makes the New Zealand Marmite. British Marmite is sold in New Zealand and Australia under the label “Our Mate”, the Library of Congress blog says, and New Zealand Marmite turns up in British shops that stock food for expatriate New Zealanders. The same post covers a legal dispute over imported jars. AP reports Sanitarium’s general manager saying imported English Marmite would not do as a substitute, because New Zealanders know their own version’s taste.

The shelf that went bare

AP’s account runs like this. A series of Christchurch earthquakes damaged the only factory that made the New Zealand version. In November 2011 Sanitarium decided the damage was too severe to carry on, and closed it. In the week of 20 March 2012 the company said its supplies had run out, and the shortage was nicknamed “Marmageddon”. Some people began auctioning their last jars online. The Library of Congress blog, written in March 2013, says the makers had begun restocking supermarket shelves the week before.

Dates in order

  • 1902: Marmite first made in England, according to FoodNavigator.
  • 1919: New Zealand has its own version, according to AP.
  • 1920: Marmite trademark registered in New Zealand, according to the Library of Congress blog and the National Business Review.
  • 1930s to 1940s: the New Zealand recipe develops, according to the National Business Review and the Library of Congress blog.
  • 1966: the Christchurch factory is gutted by fire, according to the maker’s site and the National Business Review.
  • November 2011: the factory closes after earthquake damage, according to AP.
  • March 2012: supplies run out, according to AP.
  • March 2013: restocking begins, according to the Library of Congress blog.

What we left out

Ingredients, nutrition, recipes and any advice on how much to eat; the sources we found do not give a current label. No brand claims from the maker beyond its own timeline.

Quick answers

Is New Zealand Marmite the same as British Marmite? No. AP says the New Zealand version differs in taste from the English one. Sanitarium makes it in Christchurch.

When did New Zealand start making Marmite? AP says New Zealand had its own version by 1919. The National Business Review gives the 1930s and 1940s for when the finished recipe took shape.

Why was there a Marmite shortage in New Zealand? AP says earthquakes forced Sanitarium to close the only factory that made the New Zealand version in November 2011, and supplies ran out in March 2012.

Related on this site: abel-tasman-national-park-coast-track, wellington-cable-car-lambton-quay-kelburn, kea-alpine-parrot-gear-guide

Roam first. Shop later.

/sell-with-sephari/

Scroll to Top