Tip Top: the ice cream that started in a Wellington milk bar

By Ines Keane

In 1936 a shop in Manners Street, Wellington, sold ice cream and milk shakes and little else. Te Ara, the government encyclopaedia, says the partners were confident of success. Wikipedia’s article shows dairies in Wellington and Ōpunake that still carry the Tip Top name. With summer arriving in the southern hemisphere, it seemed a good moment to set out how a milk bar became a national brand.

Who started it

Te Ara’s Dictionary of New Zealand Biography entry on Leonard Malaghan (1906 to 1967) says he left school at 14 to work in a cheese factory, qualified as a cheese factory manager four years later, and then ran a butter factory. The Dairy Division of the Department of Agriculture offered him training from visiting American experts in ice-cream manufacture, and by 1931 he was managing a Dunedin ice cream company. A customer, Bert Hayman, had experience selling ice cream. They agreed to open a shop in Wellington selling only ice creams and milk shakes. Wikipedia names the second founder Albert Hayman and gives the same first shop on Manners Street, followed the same year by two more milk bars, one in Wellington and one in Dunedin.

Te Ara says a second shop opened on Lambton Quay in March 1936, and that in July 1936 the Tip Top Ice Cream Company was registered as a manufacturing company, with a factory in Wellington. Wikipedia agrees the manufacturing company was registered in 1936.

The name

Wikipedia gives two stories. In one, Malaghan gave a boy on a train an ice cream, asked what he thought, and was told it was “tip top”. In the other, the founders heard a man on a train say his meal was tip top. Te Ara does not tell either story. It says only that the brand name soon became well known. We cannot tell you which story is right.

A summer-only factory

The 1962 plant is the detail we like best. According to Wikipedia, in November 1962 the founders opened what it calls the biggest and most technically advanced ice cream factory in the Southern Hemisphere, at Mount Wellington in Auckland. It was originally a seasonal factory, working only to produce ice cream for the summer months. Early inventions, including Topsy, Jelly Tip, FruJu and ice cream sundaes, were commercially successful enough that the site became a 24-hour, year-round operation.

Te Ara says that before that, in 1953, the Wellington company moved to a modern factory in Johnsonville, and that Tip Top grew into the largest ice cream maker in New Zealand, supplying outlets across the country.

Some products, by decade

Wikipedia’s list of brands puts them in decades. It is a list from an open encyclopaedia, so read it as a guide, not a ledger.

  • Before the 1950s: Eskimo Pie, now called Polar Pie, and Topsy, described as the first stick ice cream Tip Top produced and named after a cow.
  • 1950s: Jelly Tip, Rocky Road, Toppa, TT2’s and Joy Bar.
  • 1960s: Trumpet, first introduced in 1964, and Fruju.
  • 1980s: Goody Goody Gum Drops, among others.

Our reading: the list is long on the 1950s to 1980s and short on recent years, which may say more about the article’s editors than about the brand.

Two cities, one name

Te Ara says that by 1938 the founders were ready to move into Auckland, becoming the principal shareholders there. Wikipedia says Tip Top Ice Cream Company Auckland Limited was incorporated in May 1938 and was run as a completely separate company from the Wellington business. Te Ara says the Auckland and Wellington companies merged as General Foods Corporation (New Zealand) in 1960. Wikipedia puts the parent company’s formation at “by 1960”.

Ownership, in order

Wikipedia’s account of what followed: a merger into Watties Industries, then further plants in Christchurch and Perth. The Christchurch factory was upgraded in 1991 to meet Japanese export requirements, and closed in 2007. In April 1997 Heinz Watties sold Tip Top to a Western Australian food processor. In June 2001 the national dairy co-operative Fonterra bought it. In 2019 Fonterra sold it to Froneri, which Wikipedia describes as a joint venture between PAI Partners and Nestlé. The article says that at the time of the 2019 sale Tip Top made around 41 million litres a year, and that it is exported to Australia, Japan, Taiwan, Malaysia, Indonesia and the Pacific Islands. We have left out the sale prices.

Dates in order

  • 1936: first Manners Street shop; manufacturing company registered, according to Te Ara and Wikipedia.
  • 1938: Auckland company, according to Wikipedia (incorporated May) and Te Ara (by 1938).
  • 1953: Wellington operation moves to Johnsonville, according to Te Ara.
  • 1960: Auckland and Wellington companies merged, according to Te Ara.
  • November 1962: Mount Wellington factory opens, according to Wikipedia.
  • 1968 or 1969: merger with Wattie’s, according to Wikipedia and Te Ara respectively.
  • 2001: Fonterra buys Tip Top, according to Wikipedia.
  • 2019: sold to Froneri, according to Wikipedia.

Side by side

The Wattie’s merger is the one clear conflict. Wikipedia says General Foods merged with J. Wattie Canneries and another firm in 1968. Te Ara says General Foods completed a merger with Wattie in 1969, after a mutual exchange of directors in 1966. We show both. The Auckland date is a softer difference: “by 1938” against “May 1938” are compatible.

What kind of sources these are

Te Ara is a government encyclopaedia, and its biography was first published in 2000. Wikipedia is an open encyclopaedia that anyone can edit, and its Tip Top article leans on newspapers, an industry association page and archived material. We did not read the company’s own site.

Questions a buyer would ask

Does Sephari sell ice cream? No. Sephari is a curator of well-made goods from real places and makers, and it does not stock or ship products. This page is about a New Zealand brand’s history, not a product we carry.

What we left out

Sale prices and factory costs, the founder’s later gifts and health, the closure of milk bars, flavour discontinuations, and anything about the brand’s current range. We also left out the staff numbers.

Quick answers

When did Tip Top start? In 1936, with a shop on Manners Street, Wellington, according to Te Ara and Wikipedia.

Who started Tip Top ice cream? Leonard Malaghan and Bert Hayman, according to Te Ara.

Was the Mount Wellington factory open all year? Not at first. It was a seasonal summer factory until product success made it year-round, according to Wikipedia.

Related on this site: aoraki-mount-cook-hooker-valley-track, kakapo-flightless-parrot-rimu-breeding-season, driving-in-new-zealand-one-lane-bridges-keep-left

Roam first. Shop later.

/sell-with-sephari/

Scroll to Top