The pavlova: a pudding, a ballerina and a disputed birth certificate

By Rafe Calder

Dessert wars are usually silly. This one comes with dates, so it is worth reading the dates.

The argument is whether the pavlova belongs to New Zealand or Australia. The pudding is a meringue with a crisp shell and a soft centre, topped with whipped cream and fruit, and named for the Russian ballerina Anna Pavlova. Wikipedia says she toured both countries in the 1920s. Beyond that, the sources part company, and they do it in an orderly way.

What the thing is

Wikipedia gives the ingredients as whipped egg whites, caster sugar, an acid such as vinegar or lemon juice, cornflour and vanilla, with cream and soft fruit on top, traditionally kiwifruit, passionfruit and strawberries. It describes a crisp outer shell and a marshmallow-like centre, and notes that cornflour is often credited for the centre, although some argue it only stabilises the egg whites.

An American food magazine, Edible Seattle, gives a method from a home cook: beat the whites very stiff, add baker’s sugar, fold in a little cornflour (it says cornstarch) and a teaspoon of white vinegar, pile the mixture onto a baking sheet, bake at high heat, then turn the oven off and leave the pavlova inside. The high heat crisps the outside and the long rest sets the inside without drying it, the article says. That is one cook’s method, not a standard. It also names lemon curd and passionfruit pulp among toppings.

The Australian claim

Two sources mention the Perth story. Wikipedia says a 1974 newspaper, the Beverley Times, claimed that Bert Sachse created the dish in 1935 at the Esplanade Hotel in Perth, and calls the claim disputed. A 2001 feature in Saveur gives the first name as Herbert and the hotel as the Esplanade, and says Australians credit him with creating the dessert in 1935. A news feature in The National, a newspaper from the United Arab Emirates, says he supposedly spent a month developing the recipe for the hotel’s managers.

The New Zealand claim

The New Zealand case rests on printed recipes. Wikipedia and The National both lean on the work of a University of Otago food anthropologist whose book, The Pavlova Story, was published on 15 May 2008. The publisher, Otago University Press, calls it a work of culinary history that traces the pavlova from the ballerina’s visit to three distinct types. It says the book won Food Book of the Year at the 2009 New Zealand Guild of Food Writers’ Culinary Quills Awards.

The researcher concluded, according to Saveur, that the dessert grew through recipe swapping among New Zealand women rather than the act of one chef. The National quotes the researcher calling the two countries’ versions “parallel evolution” rather than copying. The National says the researcher’s findings have persuaded most Australians to concede New Zealand’s claim. That is the newspaper’s wording, and we have not tested it.

Dates in order, as each source gives them

The sources do not agree on which recipe counts as the first pavlova. Here they are one after another, with the source named each time.

  • 11 November 1911: Wikipedia says a “Strawberries Pavlova” recipe in the New Zealand Herald was actually an ice block or sorbet.
  • 1922: Wikipedia says a cookbook, Australian Home Cookery, included “Meringue with Fruit Filling”. One researcher it names considers this the first known recipe resembling the modern pavlova, and another disagrees.
  • 1926: Wikipedia and The National both say a Davis Gelatine jelly named after Pavlova appeared. The National says it had four colours and appeared in New Zealand. Wikipedia says the company was in Sydney and the item was a layered jelly. Saveur instead says that in 1926 a single meringue was cut in half and filled like a sponge cake.
  • 1927: Wikipedia says the Oxford English Dictionary, in 2010, recorded the first pavlova recipe as 1927, from a Davis Gelatine booklet in New Zealand, a multi-coloured jelly, and listed the origin as Australian and New Zealand. Saveur says a 1927 recipe used two meringue shells baked in tins.
  • 1928: Wikipedia says a walnut and coffee meringue recipe from Dunedin became popular across New Zealand. The National says the first recognisable pavlova, a series of small meringues, appeared in a 1928 New Zealand cookbook.
  • 1929: Wikipedia says a researcher identifies the first New Zealand “pavlova cake” recipe. The National says the classic dinner-plate size, crisp outside and spongy inside, emerged then.
  • 1933: Saveur says the name “pavlova” became attached to the dessert.
  • 1934: Wikipedia says a pavlova cake recipe appeared in the Evening Star of Dunedin on 10 November.
  • 1935: Wikipedia lists a pavlova cake recipe in The Advocate of Tasmania, and an Auckland Star advertisement of 5 September, and also the disputed Perth story.
  • 1937: Wikipedia says the Australian Women’s Weekly published a “pavlova sweet cake” recipe.

Side by side

The 1926 and 1927 entries show how much depends on definition. If a jelly named after a ballerina counts, the dessert’s birth moves back. If only a baked meringue with fruit counts, it moves forward by a few years. The sources use different tests and do not say which is correct. The National gives the Otago date of 1929 as six years before the Perth date of 1935 and eleven years before the first Australian cookbook mention. Wikipedia’s own list shows an Australian cookbook entry in 1922 that one researcher it names treats as a first pavlova-like recipe. We note the gap between the two accounts and do not resolve it.

Two small items sit outside the main line. Wikipedia mentions a 1926 story crediting an unnamed Wellington hotel chef, which the researcher could not verify. It also mentions an article in the Argus newspaper from 17 November 1928 about an “American ice-cream” named after Pavlova, with unclear relevance. Wikipedia adds that some researchers trace the roots outside both countries, to an Austro-Hungarian cake, the Spanische Windtorte.

Christmas

Wikipedia says the pavlova is a popular Christmas Day dessert in both countries, usually served chilled because December falls in summer in the Southern Hemisphere. That is the seasonal reason to look at it now, as the festive season approaches.

What kind of sources these are

Wikipedia is open-edit and summarises other people’s research. Saveur is a food magazine, here from 2001. The National is a newspaper feature. Edible Seattle is a magazine piece built on a home cook’s recipe. Otago University Press is the book’s own publisher and so describes its own product. We did not open the book.

What we left out

We left out the names of living researchers and cooks. We left out the meringue’s Swiss-town origin story, which The National itself calls disputed. We left out recipes, quantities for a home bake, prices and any claim about which country has “won”. We do not know the answer, and neither, on this evidence, does anyone else.

Roam first. Shop later.

/sell-with-sephari/

Scroll to Top